miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hello,I suggest that MessageListener also use field "Message-id" in mail's header to determine the parent thread.I think that is necessary save "Message-id" of all messages as property of Message object.Then when message input with "referral" or "in-reply-to" is necessary check this with prior saved "Message-id"Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi Miquel,No worries! Since the start of the development we care how the mail messages would be imported. It's done already! Thanks! Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Hello Thiago,First, many thanks for your reply and nice work.I don't understand your reply. It's in your TODO's list ?Checking the source code I see that Liferay search MessageId in the header "References" and "In-Reply-To" , this is good for Liferay but not for generic maillist.I recomend to use property "Message-id" in the header of the mail messages to determine the message parent. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi Miquel,The implementation was done since the beginning! We used the message-Id, references and in-reply-to headers to mark and identify the messages going back and forth from the mailing list. It's generic enough for message board and for a mailing list service. On the tests it worked perfectly. Try and let me know if something goes wrong! Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Hi Thiago,My problem is when tries to import maillist created outside of liferay.You are using MBUtil.getParentMessageId(mailMessage) to get parentId. When I analize this function, I don't see where uses "Message-Id" header. I think that only works well if maillist was created inside liferay. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi miquel,You are right! When you try to import a mialing list the MB portlet won't find the correct parent message. I opened a issue on Jira to take care of this. http://support.liferay.com/browse/LEP-7418Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Thanks Thiago,I am impatient to see improvements. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Rohan Gandhi miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Great work....Really, I am also too impatient to see the improvements in message boards... Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi Miquel,No worries! Since the start of the development we care how the mail messages would be imported. It's done already! Thanks! Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Hello Thiago,First, many thanks for your reply and nice work.I don't understand your reply. It's in your TODO's list ?Checking the source code I see that Liferay search MessageId in the header "References" and "In-Reply-To" , this is good for Liferay but not for generic maillist.I recomend to use property "Message-id" in the header of the mail messages to determine the message parent. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi Miquel,The implementation was done since the beginning! We used the message-Id, references and in-reply-to headers to mark and identify the messages going back and forth from the mailing list. It's generic enough for message board and for a mailing list service. On the tests it worked perfectly. Try and let me know if something goes wrong! Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Hi Thiago,My problem is when tries to import maillist created outside of liferay.You are using MBUtil.getParentMessageId(mailMessage) to get parentId. When I analize this function, I don't see where uses "Message-Id" header. I think that only works well if maillist was created inside liferay. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi miquel,You are right! When you try to import a mialing list the MB portlet won't find the correct parent message. I opened a issue on Jira to take care of this. http://support.liferay.com/browse/LEP-7418Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Thanks Thiago,I am impatient to see improvements. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Rohan Gandhi miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Great work....Really, I am also too impatient to see the improvements in message boards... Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Hello Thiago,First, many thanks for your reply and nice work.I don't understand your reply. It's in your TODO's list ?Checking the source code I see that Liferay search MessageId in the header "References" and "In-Reply-To" , this is good for Liferay but not for generic maillist.I recomend to use property "Message-id" in the header of the mail messages to determine the message parent. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi Miquel,The implementation was done since the beginning! We used the message-Id, references and in-reply-to headers to mark and identify the messages going back and forth from the mailing list. It's generic enough for message board and for a mailing list service. On the tests it worked perfectly. Try and let me know if something goes wrong! Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Hi Thiago,My problem is when tries to import maillist created outside of liferay.You are using MBUtil.getParentMessageId(mailMessage) to get parentId. When I analize this function, I don't see where uses "Message-Id" header. I think that only works well if maillist was created inside liferay. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi miquel,You are right! When you try to import a mialing list the MB portlet won't find the correct parent message. I opened a issue on Jira to take care of this. http://support.liferay.com/browse/LEP-7418Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Thanks Thiago,I am impatient to see improvements. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Rohan Gandhi miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Great work....Really, I am also too impatient to see the improvements in message boards... Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi Miquel,The implementation was done since the beginning! We used the message-Id, references and in-reply-to headers to mark and identify the messages going back and forth from the mailing list. It's generic enough for message board and for a mailing list service. On the tests it worked perfectly. Try and let me know if something goes wrong! Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Hi Thiago,My problem is when tries to import maillist created outside of liferay.You are using MBUtil.getParentMessageId(mailMessage) to get parentId. When I analize this function, I don't see where uses "Message-Id" header. I think that only works well if maillist was created inside liferay. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi miquel,You are right! When you try to import a mialing list the MB portlet won't find the correct parent message. I opened a issue on Jira to take care of this. http://support.liferay.com/browse/LEP-7418Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Thanks Thiago,I am impatient to see improvements. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Rohan Gandhi miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Great work....Really, I am also too impatient to see the improvements in message boards... Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Hi Thiago,My problem is when tries to import maillist created outside of liferay.You are using MBUtil.getParentMessageId(mailMessage) to get parentId. When I analize this function, I don't see where uses "Message-Id" header. I think that only works well if maillist was created inside liferay. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi miquel,You are right! When you try to import a mialing list the MB portlet won't find the correct parent message. I opened a issue on Jira to take care of this. http://support.liferay.com/browse/LEP-7418Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Thanks Thiago,I am impatient to see improvements. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Rohan Gandhi miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Great work....Really, I am also too impatient to see the improvements in message boards... Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Thiago Moreira miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Hi miquel,You are right! When you try to import a mialing list the MB portlet won't find the correct parent message. I opened a issue on Jira to take care of this. http://support.liferay.com/browse/LEP-7418Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Thanks Thiago,I am impatient to see improvements. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Rohan Gandhi miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Great work....Really, I am also too impatient to see the improvements in message boards... Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
miquel comas marti Thiago Moreira 15 Years Ago Thanks Thiago,I am impatient to see improvements. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Rohan Gandhi miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Great work....Really, I am also too impatient to see the improvements in message boards... Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Rohan Gandhi miquel comas marti 15 Years Ago Great work....Really, I am also too impatient to see the improvements in message boards... Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
blahfoo blubb 15 Years Ago This is a realy cool feature!!!But I have two issues:1. The outgoing Email has an empty "Reply to: <>" tag. Some Email clients show a invalid sender email address and you can't reply via Email. I solved the problem by rewriting the tag using postfix regular expressions (a very bad hack).2. Incoming mails are attached to the right thread, but people how have a subscription to the message board are not notified about the new "message post" via email. You can only see the new post in the web-message board.Has anybody similar problems? Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Eric Klopfer blahfoo blubb 14 Years Ago I see this thread is a little old, but I was wondering if anyone had found a better solution to #1 in the last post - the empty Reply-To tag. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Eric Klopfer blahfoo blubb 14 Years Ago I see this thread is a little old, but I was wondering if anyone had found a better solution to #1 in the last post - the empty Reply-To tag. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Mónica Rubio 14 Years Ago Hi!Can anyone say me if this functionallity is related to this one described in http://www.liferay.com/community/wiki/-/wiki/Main/Mailing%20Functionality%20in%20Liferay%20Message%20Boards?Thanks in advance Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Leão Moreira Mónica Rubio 14 Years Ago Hey Mónica,It is not the same functionality, but it is related. The functionality here described rely on a mailing list service, like Mailman. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Enos Mongake Thiago Leão Moreira 13 Years Ago Hi I have my message board configured and it sends email notificationwhat I wanna know is how can I reply to a post using my email client, like replying to a notification? Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Thiago Leão Moreira Mónica Rubio 14 Years Ago Hey Mónica,It is not the same functionality, but it is related. The functionality here described rely on a mailing list service, like Mailman. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Enos Mongake Thiago Leão Moreira 13 Years Ago Hi I have my message board configured and it sends email notificationwhat I wanna know is how can I reply to a post using my email client, like replying to a notification? Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Enos Mongake Thiago Leão Moreira 13 Years Ago Hi I have my message board configured and it sends email notificationwhat I wanna know is how can I reply to a post using my email client, like replying to a notification? Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Jacob Throgmorton 13 Years Ago Hi, I am try to mailing list feature. When i get a email notification, i tried replying to it from blackberry. This reply is not posted to liferay thread. When i debug i found that, In-Reply-To and Reference headers are missing when i reply from blackberry. When i do the same fromoutlook it is working perfectly. Any idea why this is happening?Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Leão Moreira Jacob Throgmorton 13 Years Ago Hey Jacob, This seems to be a restriction of your Blackberry software. It is not sending these header values in the mail message. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Rick Umali Thiago Leão Moreira 12 Years Ago Be advised that Liferay makes an assumption regarding the e-mail account specified in the incoming tab (when using IMAP). The code assumes that the INBOX is returned as the first folder. If the mail server is Microsoft Exchange, the INBOX is actually the fifth folder(!). Modifying the getFolder() method in MailingListMessageListener (in ext-impl/src/com/liferay/portlet/messageboards/messaging) was the only way to make this feature work with Exchange's IMAP. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Leão Moreira Rick Umali 12 Years Ago Hey Rick,Could you file a ticket about this error on our JIRA? http://issues.liferay.com. Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Thiago Leão Moreira Jacob Throgmorton 13 Years Ago Hey Jacob, This seems to be a restriction of your Blackberry software. It is not sending these header values in the mail message. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Rick Umali Thiago Leão Moreira 12 Years Ago Be advised that Liferay makes an assumption regarding the e-mail account specified in the incoming tab (when using IMAP). The code assumes that the INBOX is returned as the first folder. If the mail server is Microsoft Exchange, the INBOX is actually the fifth folder(!). Modifying the getFolder() method in MailingListMessageListener (in ext-impl/src/com/liferay/portlet/messageboards/messaging) was the only way to make this feature work with Exchange's IMAP. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Leão Moreira Rick Umali 12 Years Ago Hey Rick,Could you file a ticket about this error on our JIRA? http://issues.liferay.com. Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Rick Umali Thiago Leão Moreira 12 Years Ago Be advised that Liferay makes an assumption regarding the e-mail account specified in the incoming tab (when using IMAP). The code assumes that the INBOX is returned as the first folder. If the mail server is Microsoft Exchange, the INBOX is actually the fifth folder(!). Modifying the getFolder() method in MailingListMessageListener (in ext-impl/src/com/liferay/portlet/messageboards/messaging) was the only way to make this feature work with Exchange's IMAP. Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel Thiago Leão Moreira Rick Umali 12 Years Ago Hey Rick,Could you file a ticket about this error on our JIRA? http://issues.liferay.com. Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel
Thiago Leão Moreira Rick Umali 12 Years Ago Hey Rick,Could you file a ticket about this error on our JIRA? http://issues.liferay.com. Thanks Please sign in to reply. Reply as... Cancel